I’m always wary of new product releases. Often, they are buggy and early adopters get to be unofficial beta-testers by virtue of being the first people to use the product in real life. With Leopard, it’s no different and there are already plenty of reports of bugs and security issues. But breaking my “if it ain’t broke, don’t fix it” rule, I pre-ordered the family pack from Fry’s when it went on sale 2 weeks ago and eagerly waited for the box to arrive. I also ordered two overpriced Lexar stainless steel USB drives (what can I say? I’m a fashion whore) and 4 HD DVDs to make me feel less guilty about Fry’s $6+ base shipping fee.
When the box arrived, I thought Fry’s sent me an incomplete order. For the number of items I ordered, I expected a box twice the size (or maybe I’ve gotten use to wasteful shipping from other retailers). Where was the rest of it? I thought Fry’s had shipped OS X separately because software boxes I’m used to seeing in stores take up quite a bit of room. I was surprised to find that the OS X box is only slightly thicker than a CD case. It’s same size as the disc bundles box that comes with new Macs.
I have to praise Apple for their eco-friendlier approach to packaging design. The box is made entirely of paperboard. The dustcover has some nice reflective coating and looks like the milky way, to go with Apple’s new aurora borealis look… which looks suspiciously like Vista’s aurora borealis. The manual is printed in full color, with lots of pictures, unlike the dull computer manuals we’re all used to seeing. It might actually be fun to read, if you’re into reading manuals before you use products. It’s also printed in the USA, which is a nice touch especially these days when almost nothing is. The DVD is pressed in the US and Canada. Maybe this is a subtle political move by Apple to impress the idea of quality upon people, considering how highly anticipated Leopard is… or maybe it’s not so subtle, given the spate of problems with Made in China goods in the last year (tainted dog food and animal feed, lead paint on toys), or the minor Chinese iPod factory scandal last year.
The manuals that came with my iMac and both MacBooks are printed in China. They’re on thinner, coarser paper, and the printing (in B&W) looks really lousy. I immediately got the feeling that Apple dropped a few notches from their long-held attention to quality. When I bought my G4 years ago, everything felt so impeccably designed and packed. The paper quality was nice back then. For my MacBook Pro, the plastic slip bag that the DVD comes in had one corner folded over. This is a small detail, but it shows a little of the decline of quality as Apple tries to shave costs by moving their manufacturing to China. (Previous Macs were made in Mexico or Singapore). Given my long history of Mac ownership, it’s disappointing to see Apple trade off quality for cost savings.
So on with the show. Here are my impressions of Leopard, from the few hours that I’ve had it running.
One immediate thing I noticed is the longer load time (it also replaced my Ansel Adams landscape wallpaper without asking, which I didn’t appreciate). The login screen takes several seconds longer to show up, and the desktop takes much longer to display. I even get the dreaded spinning beachball every time I login! (Though it probably doesn’t help that I have 50 items on the desktop.) Leopard does something new that Tiger didn’t. It shows ALL your media files in preview mode. If you have a picture, a movie, PDF, etc, it will show a thumbnail of it. I don’t like this at all. Not only because it is a drain on resources, but I use the standard icons to quickly identify files by media type. I looked for a way to turn this off, but didn’t find it through the System Preferences. Speaking of which, I don’t like the new icon for it either. It a bunch of clockworks. I liked the old “light switch” icon, used in OS X since 10.1.

I’m sad to say that Leopard is looking more like XP/Vista/Office in major ways, starting with this goofy, half-assed alpha blending thing that Microsoft likes to use in Vista. For people not family with graphics geek terminology, transparency is called “alpha”. The File menu bar is where you’ll notice this first. In Tiger and before, this bar was completely opaque. Now it’s an unattractive partially transparent bar that makes text harder to read and I want to turn it off. System dialogs and menus now all do this partial transparency and blurring effect, which is not only useless, it’s detrimental. This, I can definitively say, Apple did purely for ornamental reasons and it detracts from the usability and performance of the OS. The foreground window is milky and the window behind it is partially visible, with some Gaussian blur effect done to it that makes things look out of focus. This is really unnecessary and just a waste of processor cycles, not to mention being very distracting. Another thing I wish I could turn off.
Gone also is the brushed steel texture, replaced by gradient fills. It’s really looking a lot like Microsoft Word 2005 (or whatever version it is that does this). There’s a lot more of the washed-out blue/grey color and the new folder icons are also a major step backwards, in my opinion. They look less colorful and less tight than Tiger. Not only have they been desaturated, they’ve been uglified, and remind me of X-Windows icons from my college days. Instead of looking bold and striking, the icons now are low contrast milquetoast pussies.
One improvement however, is the label of programs in the dock. There’s a speech bubble around it which increases contrast and makes it easier to read. There are no doubt plenty of improvements and nice new features to be discovered, but my first impressions of OS X is that these two major things I talked about really take away from my enjoyment of the new OS.
