This morning, I finally got the chance to unbox and test out the newly-released WD TV Live. The WDTV boards have been abuzz with rumors of a mid-October launch since at least May. In light of all the anticipation from WD fans, it’s really puzzling how WD bungled this golden PR opportunity. Many current WD owners and home theater fans have been looking forward to the WDTV 2’s release for months. Amazon had the product listed for pre-order for a few days, then it mysteriously disappeared.
The WDTV Live quietly sneaked into Best Buy over the weekend. Tipped off by forum posts, I ordered mine online on Sunday and went to pick it up yesterday. Visually, the box is almost identical to the original WDTV. It’d be hard to distinguish at a glance if the 2 boxes were put next to each other on the shelf. Inside, the contents are almost exactly the same, only with the additional of component cables. The remote and everything else is the same.
The WDTV2 is not light years ahead of the WDTV 1. It doesn’t add a host of new features. The core features and sleek interface are mostly the same, but it does offer what the WDTV user community has been asking for for a long time. The two major shortcomings of the WDTV have been addressed here, namely lack of network connectivity and lack of DTS downmixing.
I’m happy to report that both features work wonderfully, making the WDTV2 something to be excited about for those of us wanting to build a simple and inexpensive home theater network. The WDTV2 comes with an Ethernet port for wired connections, but most of us wanted built-in wireless (another commonly-requested feature). I am also very happy to report (and surprised) that wireless connectivity works using a WiFi dongle! I had a wireless N key (AirLink USB) sitting around from when I tried to hack the WDTV into a wireless device (and failed). I plugged it right in to the WDTV2, changed the network setting and it saw my share right away (DLINK DNS-321).
I streamed a few MKVs off, each encoded with various audio codec, including AAC, AC3, and DTS. DTS downmixing works flawlessly. 1080p videos now play, which the WDTV couldn’t do. With wireless connectivity out of the box and DTS downmixing, the WDTV2 is now truly portable. You are now free to put it anywhere in the house that has a WiFi signal. This is a major plus for me. With the WDTV, I had to constantly copy files to an external HDD, some of which were 6+ GB and take 20-30 minutes. Now I can stream these movies off my NAS from the living room without any cords cluttering up the TV stand.
Video previews are a new feature. If you pause over a filename for a second or two, a preview will start playing in the right column. The other view options are list view and thumbnail view.
YouTube videos played perfectly, without any noticeable buffer time. I didn’t try Pandora or Live365, since I’m not interested in listening to radio through my TV. One thing I would like to see is something like a WDTV Live Channels guide which would be a list of video sites divided by category. This may possibly be added with a future firmware upgrade. Currently, you can only go to YouTube, but there is a wealth of other video streaming sites available that could be opened up to the WDTV2 user. This would add a lot of value to the device. RMVB playback would also make the WDTV2 extremely attractive to users who download a lot of content from China/Singapore/Malaysia, as a lot of the videos from this region are encoded as RMVB. Hopefully this is something WD can include with a firmware update.
Overall, I am extremely happy with this device. It retains all the features that made the WDTV such a success and builds on them, but offered at the same price as the WDTV when it first came out ($119.99 from Best Buy) . Kudos to WD for making the device support wireless third-party dongles instead of a proprietary WD one.
Questions and comments welcomed.
EDIT: My blog commenting is currently broken. If you want to contact me, it’s zombiedoctor at gmail.